I was quoted $450 a year for basic liability through Progressive. I used to have State Farm back in CA but I think there are few agents here for some reason. Someone suggested McGraw - I'll check it out.

As for full coverage, I agree that my SH isn't worth the extra cost. On the other hand, my bike has a lot of mileage on it - over 50K - and selling it won't be easy. If it gets stolen here - not a remote possibility in Brooklyn - it would be in my favor to have it insured. So far I've had good luck parking it on the street under cover. It's garaged for the next few months now.

Thanks for the responses!

 

I'm paying $139 for liability with Progressive here in Phoenix, it was less than that when i lived in Atlanta, like $120 or something. Chickenstrip, you must have some hardcore tickets.

 

I have McGraw's. Every other one of the several quotes I got for minimum legal liability on the VTR was over $250/yr. I pay $80/yr with McGraw. Don't know about full coverage cost or if they write in N.Y. but here's a link.

http://ridewithmcgraw.com/net.data/ride.ndm/motorcycle
The McGraw Group of Affliated Companies

 

Geico

less than a $1000 for full coverage on four bikes

 

I do have a couple of tickets, but they're from four years ago. Turns out that Allstate in NY keeps these on file for 5 years. Allstate in CA keeps 'em for 3.

I think the big difference between your situation and mine is Phoenix vs. Brooklyn. New York is expensive in pretty much all ways, and where crime is concerned even more so. Not that where I live is a hell hole, by no means, but there are a lot of people here and along with that goes increased crime.

Regarding tickets .... One thing that burns me up is that the two tickets I mentioned are the only tickets I've gotten in 30 years of riding and driving, and one of 'em is bogus. And yet insurance companies don't take that into acct. They appear to abitrarily set a time limit. Whatya gonna do?

 

Hey... I'm right here in Mount Vernon NY... Progressive and Geico are by far your best choices... all the other big players are laughable...

I moved from college in North Carolina where I was paying 300 a year full coverage, to Chicago, which doubled the cost, to NY where it tripled from that until I dropped everything but liability.... I have no tickets, no accidents... it doesn't matter.

I have Progressive right now simply because Geico increased my rates for no reason other than they said a lot of people in my area are making claims and getting tickets, so I need to pay more... I switched to Progressive and saved 30 bucks. I don't remember off hand, but I think it's around 340 a year just for liability... I honestly don't think you'll do better than that even with a clean record.

As for you bike getting stolen... trust me, if it's on the street get at least 2 locks... one for the front wheel, and a one with a cable long enough to chain it to something they can't move. When I was in Hoboken for 1 year with the bike on the street, I went through 3 ignition locks in one year. If you want to make sure you keep it, a switch on the battery under the seat, or a separate kill switch isn't a bad idea.

Good Luck,

J.

 

You might try e-surence online. I had been progressive but switched. I'm in albany, not the the city, but up here I pay $75! no collision or comprehensive, but still 100/300 liability. Had a ticket 4 years ago, but Esurence only went back 39 months. Thats why I switched. Progressive was still counting it and would have been $40 more.
Unless you are forced to have collision (loan?) it doesn't make sense. Blue book is too low, and there are plenty of good cheap used parts available.

 

Ooops - didn't think in terms of getting stolen... I guess more of a concern downstate and in the city. Now those prices you guys are seeing makes more sese to me....
Good luck

 

i use geico in texas and i pay $21.00 a month on 2 bikes.